5-day versus 3-day versus Mentzer’s HIT – apply within!

  • This topic has 7 voices and 23 replies.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 24 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #6602

    RussiB
    Keymaster

    Hey all,I am currently doing CNS and want to ensure I am doing the right training. A couple weeks ago I started implementing a 5-day split which seemed to be working okay but left me feeling quite drained, especially towards the 5th and 6th days after my last re-feed.Then I got into a conversation with someone about using high-intensity resistance training after a carb nite rather than HIIT and all my previous ideas flew out the window when I read Mike Mentzer's Heavy Duty Training.I train early AM and enjoy training most days but the results are the most important aspect for me and as I am on CNS maintaining existing muscle mass whilst maximising fat loss is my goal.What resistance training program would you recommend? Thank you!

    #142371

    Richard Schmitt
    Moderator

    Personally I don't think upping that intensity is going to make you feel any better. Especially if it is constant HIIT through the week. You could that program Post-CN and then why not use a Push/Pull/Leg split?

    #142372

    RussiB
    Guest

    So you think stick with the 5-day or 3-day split?Stupid question time - which is better in your opinion for a CNSer relatively new to lifting?

    #142373

    Richard Schmitt
    Moderator

    3 Days, Push/Pull/Legs for sure, get used to using equipment and used to doing the basics. Maybe even look into a simple variation of 5/3/1 or Starting Strength

    #142374

    RussiB
    Guest

    Thanks Tex, leg-end!

    #142375

    Roadblock
    Participant

    And HIIT 1 or 2 days after your CN is recommended as well.RB

    #142376

    BenjaminD
    Member

    So you think stick with the 5-day or 3-day split?Stupid question time - which is better in your opinion for a CNSer relatively new to lifting?

    You can really do whatever you want as long as you stay consistent and understand the difference between a 3- and 5-day split. A 3-day split, in my opinion, allows you to train a little longer with more intensity as you have the benefit of more recovery time through the course of the week. A 5-day split is fine, but I would drop down the overall volume while keeping up the intensity.What I have been doing lately is a 3-day routine cycled over 4 days. So essentially I have 3 workouts (A=squat/legs, B=deadlift/back, C=bench/press) and just cycle through them and don't keep any workouts "fixed" to certain days (Monday is not always chest and biceps!) If I feel good and want to train an extra day, I just move to the next workout in the cycle; conversely, if I feel like taking a day off, I just move the next workout back a day. This has been working very well for me, in part because it is highly adaptable to how I feel but also due to the fact that I only hit 3-4 exercises in a session.Programmed routines are great but nowhere is it written in stone that you NEED to do them a certain way. Do a 3-day routine, 5-days a week (like me) or vice versa. The important thing is to be consistent and get good work done!

    #142377

    Gl;itch.e
    Member

    Training should match your Diet. And likewise Diet should match your Training. So it all depends on what you want to do.Since you are on CNS and you are looking to lose fat (while retaining/building muscle) you could do with a program with an emphasis on higher reps and volume in the first few days after a carb nite and then a lower rep/volume, more strength focused workouts as the week goes on. Kind of like a reversed PHAT routine. •Day 1: Upper Body Power•Day 2: Lower Body Power•Day 3: Carbnite•Day 4: Back and Shoulders Hypertrophy•Day 5: Lower Body Hypertrophy•Day 6: Chest and Arms Hypertrophy•Day 7: RestSomething like that. But possibly less total days on account of the recovery aspect.

    #142378

    Richard Schmitt
    Moderator

    I would not recommend PHAT to someone who is starting out with both CNS and training

    #142379

    BenjaminD
    Member

    I would not recommend PHAT to someone who is starting out with both CNS and training

    I agree. Not because PHAT is anything special, but to me it's overly complicated (for a beginner).Also, I would do my heaviest/higher intensity work with relatively high volume in the couple days following your CN- not in the last two days before your carb night. Take advantage of the glycogen for your heavy work and you can stick with some more volume/low intensity bodybuilding type work prior to your CN.

    #142380

    Gl;itch.e
    Member

    I would not recommend PHAT to someone who is starting out with both CNS and training

    I wasnt recommending the PHAT routine exclusively. Just something with that kind of setup if he must do a bodypart split. I was not aware of this guys training status.Someone new to training can do just about anything and get results! I wouldnt recommend a bodypart split for someone who's goal is fatloss specifically and especially not for a beginner! A full body routine would be better. Beginners need more frequency on the main exercises in order to learn how to do them.  OP you are feeling drained because of the diet and should adjust training to compensate. Why not try Kiefer's own Shockwave Protocol which was designed for CNS in mind? Or find a template like Madcows 5x5 that allows for more frequency of the main movements. Youd need to judge your own experience level here.

    #142381

    Gl;itch.e
    Member

    I would not recommend PHAT to someone who is starting out with both CNS and training

    I agree. Not because PHAT is anything special, but to me it's overly complicated (for a beginner).Also, I would do my heaviest/higher intensity work with relatively high volume in the couple days following your CN- not in the last two days before your carb night. Take advantage of the glycogen for your heavy work and you can stick with some more volume/low intensity bodybuilding type work prior to your CN.

    Whats your rationale here? Strength work is not that heavily dependant on glycogen. That would be higher rep/higher volume, almost endurance type work. Hence my recommendation for the higher rep/volume during the period directly after Carb Nite. This would be so that a. You can actually perform the higher rep and volume while glycogen levels are high and b. You are then also depleting glycogen to enhance fat burning for the rest of the week. The strength work should not suffer in this regard. If it did then the Anabolic Diet wouldnt have worked at all! And work it did for strength (not so great for bodycomp IMO but thats another topic)

    #142382

    Richard Schmitt
    Moderator

    That's why I mentioned a simpler variation to 5/3/1 or Starting Strength. You can easily have accessories to a day that you're strength training for. While PHAT is great, I still wouldn't recommend it to a beginner. Regardless if they make great gains through that training, OP is also a beginner in regards to CNS. SW is not an option at the moment because it is not available the public. I do understand what you're saying, but I don't agree with doing a PHAT split

    #142383

    Gl;itch.e
    Member

    That's why I mentioned a simpler variation to 5/3/1 or Starting Strength. You can easily have accessories to a day that you're strength training for. While PHAT is great, I still wouldn't recommend it to a beginner. Regardless if they make great gains through that training, OP is also a beginner in regards to CNS. SW is not an option at the moment because it is not available the public. I do understand what you're saying, but I don't agree with doing a PHAT split

    And I agree with you disagreeing with the PHAT split! (: It was only for the break up of the days and volume in order to fit with the diet. A true beginner would certainly be better off with something like 5/3/1 or Starting Strength. Though IMO 5/3/1 is really more for intermediate people with some experience and strength. The 5x5 routine would be better for a true beginner just for the frequency of exercises. Youve got to learn the exercises before you can actually train them!

    #142384

    BenjaminD
    Member

    I would not recommend PHAT to someone who is starting out with both CNS and training

    I agree. Not because PHAT is anything special, but to me it's overly complicated (for a beginner).Also, I would do my heaviest/higher intensity work with relatively high volume in the couple days following your CN- not in the last two days before your carb night. Take advantage of the glycogen for your heavy work and you can stick with some more volume/low intensity bodybuilding type work prior to your CN.

    Whats your rationale here? Strength work is not that heavily dependant on glycogen. That would be higher rep/higher volume, almost endurance type work. Hence my recommendation for the higher rep/volume during the period directly after Carb Nite. This would be so that a. You can actually perform the higher rep and volume while glycogen levels are high and b. You are then also depleting glycogen to enhance fat burning for the rest of the week. The strength work should not suffer in this regard. If it did then the Anabolic Diet wouldnt have worked at all! And work it did for strength (not so great for bodycomp IMO but thats another topic)

    Personally, I don't have a problem with training heavy while deep into an ULC period but it appears that lots of people are practically zombies by mid-week. Therefore, my rationale was that this individual is probably like the rest of the population and wouldn't be able to handle moving heavy loads while depleted. However, if the OP can handle it then why the hell not. Furthermore, I find it is easier to work at a lower intensity while fatigued. Consider this: While run-down and depleted later in the week, is it more difficult to squat a 1RM (100% intensity) or squat 50% of your 1RM for 10 reps?

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 24 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

5-day versus 3-day versus Mentzer’s HIT – apply within!

Please login / register in order to chat with others.

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?