- This topic has 8 voices and 27 replies.
-
AuthorPosts
-
July 30, 2013 at 3:49 pm #9293
apisula2000MemberI noticed looking through the book again for the off day for backloading example, Kiefer has pizza for dinner. Is this recommending for BD vs SA off days? Seems strange to have a high glycemic carb on my off day.
July 30, 2013 at 4:03 pm #193217
getbigordietryingMemberthe principles of carb backloading are based on consuming high glycemic carbs. either way pizza's fat content is usually so high that i feel like it could react like a low glycemic carb in your body because the fat slows down the release of insulin.
July 30, 2013 at 4:12 pm #193218
Trevor G FullbrightModeratorthe principles of carb backloading are based on consuming high glycemic carbs. either way pizza's fat content is usually so high that i feel like it could react like a low glycemic carb in your body because the fat slows down the release of insulin.
This is incorrect.Fat, particularly saturated fat will increase the insulin response so that glucose will clear before fat enters the system. Pizza is a great off day carb because it is more filling then say... rice. I could eat 300g of carbs from rice like nothing, but from pizza that's harder. Some people need off days carbs because of their training load or their goals.
July 30, 2013 at 4:20 pm #193219
apisula2000Memberthe principles of carb backloading are based on consuming high glycemic carbs. either way pizza's fat content is usually so high that i feel like it could react like a low glycemic carb in your body because the fat slows down the release of insulin.
This is incorrect.Fat, particularly saturated fat will increase the insulin response so that glucose will clear before fat enters the system. Pizza is a great off day carb because it is more filling then say... rice. I could eat 300g of carbs from rice like nothing, but from pizza that's harder. Some people need off days carbs because of their training load or their goals.
Thanks for the explanation. Helps out a lot. At this point I am only SA and not DB, so I don't think pizza is in my list of goals for off days, but I plan on going DB after the summer.
July 30, 2013 at 7:53 pm #193220
T-Bone300Memberthe principles of carb backloading are based on consuming high glycemic carbs. either way pizza's fat content is usually so high that i feel like it could react like a low glycemic carb in your body because the fat slows down the release of insulin.
This is incorrect.Fat, particularly saturated fat will increase the insulin response so that glucose will clear before fat enters the system. Pizza is a great off day carb because it is more filling then say... rice. I could eat 300g of carbs from rice like nothing, but from pizza that's harder. Some people need off days carbs because of their training load or their goals.
I thought the explanation here was that as these specific fats take so long to process (e.g. 2-8 hours) then this has no real impact on the insulin spike and is also beneficial during sleep to prevent hypoglycemia. If memory serves this was in the podcast with Jonathan Watson (the Brit from Propane Fitness), although I believe they used ice cream as the example.
July 30, 2013 at 7:56 pm #193221
Trevor G FullbrightModeratorthe principles of carb backloading are based on consuming high glycemic carbs. either way pizza's fat content is usually so high that i feel like it could react like a low glycemic carb in your body because the fat slows down the release of insulin.
This is incorrect.Fat, particularly saturated fat will increase the insulin response so that glucose will clear before fat enters the system. Pizza is a great off day carb because it is more filling then say... rice. I could eat 300g of carbs from rice like nothing, but from pizza that's harder. Some people need off days carbs because of their training load or their goals.
I thought the explanation here was that as these specific fats take so long to process (e.g. 2-8 hours) then this has no real impact on the insulin spike and is also beneficial during sleep to prevent hypoglycemia. If memory serves this was in the podcast with Jonathan Watson (the Brit from Propane Fitness), although I believe they used ice cream as the example.
It's actually both true. The fats take awhile to process so it doesn't slow an insulin response, but the body tends to release more insulin to clear the glucose to allow the fat to be used as energy as soon as the glucose/insulin levels return to baseline.
July 30, 2013 at 9:30 pm #193222
Tiago NicolauParticipantSo talking about that, what is the real difference between eating a trashy meal last and a clean 1st if the fat wont be the issue?
July 30, 2013 at 9:46 pm #193223
T-Bone300MemberSorry, don't understand the question can you reframe pleaseThe difference between trashy and clean is more about things like the hydrogenated fats, additives etc... Dextrose and sticky rice are considered clean, doughnuts and cakes dirtyMainstream believes would probably classify brown wholegrain rice as clean and white rice as trashy due to the high glycemic index
July 30, 2013 at 10:30 pm #193224
Tiago NicolauParticipantYeah that wasnt my question hehe,My question is about eating carbs with no fat as the 1st backload and then eat the fatty bakload in the end,I thought it was because of the fat that slowed the absortion, but seemingly it is the opossite, so why do we have to eat the fattier backload in the end?
July 30, 2013 at 10:32 pm #193225
Trevor G FullbrightModeratorYeah that wasnt my question hehe,My question is about eating carbs with no fat as the 1st backload and then eat the fatty bakload in the end,I thought it was because of the fat that slowed the absortion, but seemingly it is the opossite, so why do we have to eat the fattier backload in the end?
To avoid having high bloodglucose/insulin levels and high free fatty acid levels at the same time.If you keep your carb window short it doesn't matter at all, but if you are eating within a 4-6 hour window you need to keep it in mind.
July 30, 2013 at 10:38 pm #193226
Tiago NicolauParticipantSo if one works out at 21pm and only have 1-2 hours of feeding, it could even be optimal to eat a complete spectrum of macro?since it inst the absortion thats the issue, i guess its ok to do that 🙂
July 30, 2013 at 10:39 pm #193227
Trevor G FullbrightModeratorSo if one works out at 21pm and only have 1-2 hours of feeding, it could even be optimal to eat a complete spectrum of macro?since it inst the absortion thats the issue, i guess its ok to do that 🙂
Yep
July 30, 2013 at 11:37 pm #193228
TCBParticipantthe principles of carb backloading are based on consuming high glycemic carbs. either way pizza's fat content is usually so high that i feel like it could react like a low glycemic carb in your body because the fat slows down the release of insulin.
This is incorrect.Fat, particularly saturated fat will increase the insulin response so that glucose will clear before fat enters the system. Pizza is a great off day carb because it is more filling then say... rice. I could eat 300g of carbs from rice like nothing, but from pizza that's harder. Some people need off days carbs because of their training load or their goals.
I thought the explanation here was that as these specific fats take so long to process (e.g. 2-8 hours) then this has no real impact on the insulin spike and is also beneficial during sleep to prevent hypoglycemia. If memory serves this was in the podcast with Jonathan Watson (the Brit from Propane Fitness), although I believe they used ice cream as the example.
It's actually both true. The fats take awhile to process so it doesn't slow an insulin response, but the body tends to release more insulin to clear the glucose to allow the fat to be used as energy as soon as the glucose/insulin levels return to baseline.
If I'm not mistaken, doesn't the problem then arise with your next meal, because then the body is in process of digesting those fats, thus blunting the new insulin spike you're trying to create?That's the reason I've been going off of for keeping my first CN/BL meal low fat, second (if I have one) low-med fat, and last meal of the night as much fat as I want.. Off base?
July 31, 2013 at 12:08 am #193229
Richard SchmittModeratorCarbs and Fats provide the insulin response combine. Fats and Proteins provide a blunted insulin response. It's the combination of these macros that trigger events with ULC and backload meals.
July 31, 2013 at 3:11 am #193230
TCBParticipantCarbs and Fats provide the insulin response combine. Fats and Proteins provide a blunted insulin response. It's the combination of these macros that trigger events with ULC and backload meals.
Was this covered somewhere in one of the books and I totally glossed over it? Cuz I'm leaning toward the "Say what?" side of things, ha.Wouldn't this provide an argument, then, to go high fat and high carb for all CN/CBL meals?
-
AuthorPosts
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.