Stevia vs Splenda

  • This topic has 8 voices and 18 replies.
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 19 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #858

    Vern
    Keymaster

    Keifer used to recommend Stevia such as in CNS more recently such as the current Men Fitness article he suggested Splenda.  Anybody know why or the pros & cons to each?  Since once upon a time I was on the wrong side of the type II diabetes line I took to Stevia such as for a bitter coffee sweetner.  Thoughts? 

    #37691

    Kris1501
    Member

    Stevia… I'm pretty sure it's the only all natural sweetener out there….get the sweet leaf one. Nothing wrong with Splenda but it does contain a tiny amount of Maltodextrin in each packet....

    #37692

    Damon Amato
    Participant

    why the sweet leaf one?

    #37693

    Kris1501
    Member

    The “Stevia in the raw” is cut with dextrose.. Although only a tiny amount, so wouldn't make a huge difference either way… Sweet Leaf is fail safe in my opinion… All it contains is the leaf extract and fiber

    #37694

    Richard Schmitt
    Moderator

    I rarely use Splenda with coffee, just I've been using DaVinci's Sugar Free Syrup with my coffee though. and I just placed an order for that Sweet Leaf Stevia =D

    #37695

    Vern
    Guest

    Kris great reply that is exactly the type info I was looking for.  I used the coffee as an example but actually what I was thinking about it for was everybody says the Blend H from PF is really bad without a sweetner.  I wondered if the Splenda worked better for it or whether the Stevia would also work well. 

    #37696

    amedio
    Guest

    Kris great reply that is exactly the type info I was looking for.  I used the coffee as an example but actually what I was thinking about it for was everybody says the Blend H from PF is really bad without a sweetner.  I wondered if the Splenda worked better for it or whether the Stevia would also work well. 

    Blend H is...different to say the least. I ordered my H already mixed with stevia from PF. Is the most awkward tasting protein shake I have ever consumed, but I always manage to chug it without vomitting. It grows on you.

    #37697

    Kris1501
    Member

    haha…very true. I'm not sure if my taste buds have been destroyed….but it definitely starts tasting a little better after a few weeks.

    #37698

    Vern
    Guest

    I ordered mine in orange unsweetened and tried it PWO today with a half a scoop of Stevia.  It was tolerable.  8)

    #37699

    Naomi Most
    Member

    Keifer used to recommend Stevia such as in CNS more recently such as the current Men Fitness article he suggested Splenda.  Anybody know why or the pros & cons to each?  Since once upon a time I was on the wrong side of the type II diabetes line I took to Stevia such as for a bitter coffee sweetner.  Thoughts?

    Just a personal preference thing.  You should see the massive amounts of Splenda Kiefer puts in his coffee, holy crap. Talk about "inner fat kid".Stevia happens to be MY preference -- I like the security of knowing there are exactly ZERO carbs in my sweetener. (Splenda packets contain maltodextrin, so their zero-carb claim is kinda bogus, it's just that the amount in that packet is a lot less than 1g.)The Vanilla Bean flavor of Sweet Leaf liquid stevia is my current addiction.

    #37700

    Richard Schmitt
    Moderator

    Keifer used to recommend Stevia such as in CNS more recently such as the current Men Fitness article he suggested Splenda.  Anybody know why or the pros & cons to each?  Since once upon a time I was on the wrong side of the type II diabetes line I took to Stevia such as for a bitter coffee sweetner.  Thoughts?

    Just a personal preference thing.  You should see the massive amounts of Splenda Kiefer puts in his coffee, holy crap. Talk about "inner fat kid".Stevia happens to be MY preference -- I like the security of knowing there are exactly ZERO carbs in my sweetener. (Splenda packets contain maltodextrin, so their zero-carb claim is kinda bogus, it's just that the amount in that packet is a lot less than 1g.)The Vanilla Bean flavor of Sweet Leaf liquid stevia is my current addiction.

    I was looking into buying some of the BetterStevia Powder, but I'm afraid of purchasing one that has trace carbs into it. I bought the 1lb BetterStevia because of knowing it doesn't have anything like that, but with the packets, I'm not really certain if they don't have any those trace carbs. Any thoughts on this? I keep finding stevia extract on amazon, but not certain which one is acceptable.

    #37701

    AdamFiddler
    Guest

    Seems like more than a personal preference given that Stevia's been used for centuries while Splenda (in 2005) was shown to have some ill-effects on gut bacteria populations in animals. Also, Splenda has a Glycemic Index of like 80, so how on earth could it be a good idea to use in morning coffee?  Hopefully I'm missing something here...Adam

    #37702

    dawatts22
    Member

    haha...very true. I'm not sure if my taste buds have been destroyed....but it definitely starts tasting a little better after a few weeks.

    +1

    #37703

    Richard Schmitt
    Moderator

    Another curious thought, are the DaVainci Sugar Free Syrups considered off limits? Or is good like BetterStevia?

    #37704

    Brandon D Christ
    Participant

    Another curious thought, are the DaVainci Sugar Free Syrups considered off limits? Or is good like BetterStevia?

    Typically sugar free syrups are a heads up because a lot of times they contain the sugar alcohol sorbitol.  Make sure you check the ingredients.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 19 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Stevia vs Splenda

Please login / register in order to chat with others.

Log in with your credentials

Forgot your details?